10 Most Underrated Game of the Year-Nominated Video Games

February 24, 2026 - 10:49

The annual Game of the Year awards celebrate the industry's brightest blockbusters, titles that dominate headlines and sales charts. Yet, nestled among the usual suspects are nominees that, despite their prestigious recognition, never quite captured the mainstream spotlight they deserved. These are the underrated gems—games that delivered profound, innovative, or exceptionally polished experiences but remained in the shadows of their more famous peers.

These titles often hail from smaller studios or explore niche genres. They might lack the marketing juggernaut of a major publisher or feature quieter, more introspective storytelling. While earning a nomination is a monumental achievement, the conversation around them frequently fades after the ceremony, overshadowed by debates over the ultimate winner. Their inclusion on the shortlist proves their exceptional quality, yet they struggle to achieve the same lasting cultural footprint.

For discerning players, these nominees represent a curated list of must-play experiences. They are frequently the passion projects where creative risks flourish, unburdened by the need to appeal to the broadest possible audience. Seeking them out is a rewarding endeavor, offering some of the most unique and memorable gameplay of the year. Their nomination is not just an honor, but a beacon for players looking to discover the true depth and diversity that the gaming landscape has to offer beyond the usual headlines.